Unearthing Rival Secrets and Harnessing the Power of Competitive Analysis in Private Equity


What to consider

Private Equity (PE) is akin to a highly complex, fast-evolving battlefield. Information, in this sphere, is the most potent weapon that firms can wield. This article delves into the vital role of competitive analysis within the realm of PE. It elucidates how firms can assess their rivals, gain insights into their strategies, strengths, and weaknesses, and use these findings to make strategic investment decisions. The ultimate aim is to maximize returns while minimizing risk.

Demystifying Competitive Analysis: A Deeper Dive

In the PE landscape, merely staying informed is no longer sufficient to maintain a competitive edge. The current dynamics demand a profound understanding of the competitive terrain. A systematic competitive analysis provides this much-needed perspective. It goes beyond a basic market overview and competitor profiling to discern underlying threats, opportunities, and patterns. This vital intelligence empowers firms to devise robust strategies to enhance returns.

Competitive analysis involves a comprehensive examination of competitor products, sales, and marketing strategies. It aids in identifying both direct and indirect competitors while understanding their objectives and policies. This process can expose gaps in the market, potential risk factors, market trends, and growth opportunities.

Moreover, it’s not just about observing the competition; firms can also learn from them. By studying successful competitors, firms can emulate effective strategies. Conversely, they can avoid the pitfalls and failures experienced by less successful competitors.

Case Studies: The Role of Competitive Analysis in Investment Decisions

Let’s delve deeper into this concept through some practical examples. First, we consider the case of Blackstone Group, a leading PE firm with an eye on investment opportunities in the technology sector. Blackstone conducted an exhaustive competitive analysis, which led them to uncover a niche market where a potential target company, Cylance, held a solid competitive position.

This analysis entailed a thorough review of Cylance’s competitors, assessing their strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats (SWOT). Additionally, it examined the financial performance, business models, and strategic alliances of these competitors. The competitive analysis helped Blackstone gauge the potential growth and profitability of investing in Cylance. Their investment proved successful, delivering high returns.

In contrast, consider the case of Vista Equity Partners. Vista overlooked the significance of competitive analysis, leading to a misunderstanding of the market dynamics. Consequently, they made a misguided investment in Misys, a retail company. The lack of an in-depth analysis led to an underestimation of the competition and overestimation of the potential for growth and profit. This ill-informed decision resulted in subpar returns, highlighting the perils of bypassing competitive analysis in the PE sphere.

In the Trenches: The Implications of Competitive Analysis

Understanding your competition is crucial to surviving and thriving in the intense world of private equity. This isn’t a mere luxury or an option that firms can consider – it’s an absolute necessity. It isn’t hyperbole to state that the success or failure of a firm’s investment decisions hinges on the depth and breadth of their competitive analysis.

Firms need to remember that competitive analysis isn’t a one-time task. It’s an ongoing process that requires updating as the market and competitors evolve. A static, outdated analysis can lead to incorrect assumptions and poor investment decisions. Firms need to adapt their strategies based on the latest competitive intelligence.

Beyond the Financials: A Holistic Approach

While financials are a critical aspect of any PE decision-making process, competitive analysis extends beyond mere numbers. It delves into the intricacies of each potential investment – their unique selling propositions, their positioning in the market, the strength of their leadership, their operational efficiencies, and more. It examines these factors against the backdrop of the competition, offering a holistic view of the company’s standing in the market.

For instance, Blackstone’s successful investment in Cylance wasn’t solely based on the company’s financial performance. It also considered Cylance’s unique product offerings, its leadership in the cybersecurity space, and the strength of its customer base, which together formed a compelling case for investment.

Staying Ahead in the Game: A Proactive Approach

In the world of PE, information is valuable currency. However, the benefits aren’t derived from just having information; it’s about having it before others do and using it effectively. Competitive analysis is a proactive approach that allows firms to stay one step ahead. By consistently monitoring the competition, firms can detect shifts in market dynamics early on, seize emerging opportunities, and avoid potential pitfalls.

For instance, if Vista Equity Partners had performed a thorough competitive analysis before investing in Misys, they might have identified the strong competitive forces at play. This could have prompted them to reassess the investment or revise their growth strategy for Misys, potentially averting the disappointing returns.

The Road Ahead: Integrating Competitive Analysis into PE Strategy

The potential of competitive analysis in the PE arena is vast and largely untapped. To reap the benefits, firms need to make it an integral part of their investment strategy. This requires not just the commitment of time and resources but also a shift in mindset.

Instead of viewing competitive analysis as a discrete exercise, firms should see it as a continuous process. It should be embedded into every stage of the investment cycle – from deal sourcing and due diligence to portfolio management and exit planning.

Moreover, competitive analysis shouldn’t be confined to a firm’s investment team. It should permeate every layer of the organization, fostering a culture of competitive intelligence. This will ensure that all strategic decisions, whether big or small, are guided by a clear understanding of the competitive landscape.


In the high-stakes world of private equity, competitive analysis is an indispensable tool that illuminates the path to success. By offering deep insights into market dynamics and competitor strategies, it helps firms make strategic investment decisions, maximize returns, and mitigate risks. As the PE landscape continues to evolve, the importance of competitive analysis will only grow. Therefore, firms that master this vital tool will be better positioned to navigate the challenges and seize the opportunities that lie ahead.

Start a Conversation

Thank you for your interest in Cicero Group. Please select from the options below to get in touch with us.